introduction image

Protest at the US Department of Education against federal education cuts and the Trump administration's support for private school vouchers, 22 July 2017.

Picture by: Bob Korn | Alamy Stock Photo

Article link copied.

Trump 2.0: Could Trump actually ban the Department of Education?

17-year-old Reva Sobti looks at what might happen to the US education system under Trump

In September 2023, Donald Trump took to social media and posted his plan for the US education system if he was elected to office. The plan’s defining feature was to eliminate the Department of Education (DOE).

Trump’s remarks are deeply rooted in the Republican belief that the government has used the DOE as a tool for indoctrinating classrooms with “liberal ideologies”. Since winning the presidency in November, he’s promised to “cut federal funding for any school pushing critical race theory, radical gender ideology, and other inappropriate racial, sexual, or political content on our children”.

In his first term (2016–20), Trump made budget cuts, but his new administration, with ambitious goals to cut federal funding, could complete the dissolution of the DOE. So far, he has not delved into the details of how he would proceed.

Trump also argues that education should be in the hands of the states, rather than the federal government. Currently, each state has the power to create education policy relating to curriculums, rules and regulations; however, the DOE is able to control national initiatives through their funds.

The DOE, as Americans know today, was founded by Jimmy Carter in 1980. Today, its mission is to ensure “​​equal educational opportunity for every individual”. It funds resources to public primary and secondary schools, spearheading initiatives for students from low-income families, and coordinating federal education programmes – providing higher education financial aid for students through FAFSA (Free Application for Federal Student Aid).

For instance, the DOE has a crucial role in reinforcing the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), so without federal oversight some of the inclusive initiatives could create funding disparities in quality and access.

Cutting DOE funds would mean firing a large number of government employees with expertise in education. Education expert Clare McCann explainsthat DOE employees are incredibly adept at dispersing funds and determining levels of need. She told ABC News, “The civil servants who work at the Department of Education are true experts in the field.”

One of the main issueswith the elimination of the Department of Education is who will take on the responsibility of the student loan programme. This is currently a $1.6tn dollar programme that many students have come to rely on.

It is possible that these funding duties, accordingto Tim Villegas from the Maryland Coalition for Inclusive Education, would simply go to another department.

image

Picture by: Wikipedia

On the other side, education analyst Neal McCluskey from the libertarian think tank Cato Institute believes that eliminating the DOE may not have as grave consequences as one might believe. He said existing federal initiatives can continue with funds to and in the hands of the states

Trump has chosen Linda McMahon to serve as the secretary of education. Her previous experience with education is limited. She was on the board of trustees at Connecticut’s Sacred Heart University and the state’s board of education on 2009, but is mainly known for being the founder and CEO of the World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE).

She is one of Trump’s numerous controversial picks – many believe he is prioritising antics over experience. Responding to criticism of her appointment, she said, “I’ve witnessed the transformative power of education, both in the classroom and also in apprenticeship programs. All students should be equipped with the necessary skills to prepare them for a successful future.”

Trump’s pick affirms that he places little significance on the Department of Education.

Harbingers’ Magazine hit the streets of Los Angeles to better understand what local high schoolers and teachers have to say.

Overall, they are sceptical of the supposed good intent that Trump claims he has when it comes to eliminating the DOE.

One teacher voiced concern for her future students: “You need to have the department to organise schools and make sure that we educate the youth of tomorrow.”

An eleventh grade student (who chose to remain anonymous) believes “it shows how intelligence is not being favoured in America anymore and how we aren’t making it a priority.”

She says Trump’s proposal is a step back for the nation, adding, “We need to hold education and reading to the standards we hold other crises to in our nation, because eventually it’s going to become a problem that we can’t solve in a generation.”

Another student was initially unsure of what the DOE’s purpose was. However, after a little research, he came to the conclusion, “I don’t think it’s necessary [to get rid of the DOE], especially getting rid of financial aid for students.”

This is not the first time Republicans have attempted to get rid of the Department of Education. In 2023, the House voted on a bill to eradicate the department, but it failed to make it through to the Senate as it received only 161 Republican votes and none from Democrats.

If Trump wanted to carry out his plan, he would need to work with Congress to draft a bill and win the majority of votes in both the House and the Senate. As we anticipate the next four years of a new Trump administration, federal changes remain unclear – leaving many Americans nervous for the future of education.

Written by:

author_bio

Reva Sobti

The Harbinger Prize 2024 (Overall Winner)

Contributor

United States

Reva Sobti was born in 2008 and currently studies in the United States. She plans to pursue a higher education at one of the T-25 universities to major in Sociology, Business, or Biology. Reva won the Harbinger Prize 2024 and plans to continue writing about social issues.

In her free time, she loves to read, watch movies, bake, play volleyball, and eat good food. A fan of travelling, Reva has so far visited 16 countries.

She speaks English, Hindi, Punjabi, and Spanish

Edited by:

author_bio

Emily Dorman

International Affairs Section Editor 2024

Florida, United States

education

🌍 Join the World's Youngest Newsroom—Create a Free Account

Sign up to save your favourite articles, get personalised recommendations, and stay informed about stories that Gen Z worldwide actually care about. Plus, subscribe to our newsletter for the latest stories delivered straight to your inbox. 📲

Login/Register